The Case Against Antonella Barba

February 24th, 2007 · 13 Comments · Tagged as Antonella Barba · American Idol

Everybody seems to love Antonella Barba. She’s the darling of America. At the very least, she seems to be the Idol contestant that everyone is talking about these days. Why? Well, there’s one simply answer: Antonella Barba is hot.

But “hot” does not make the next American Idol. Here, we make the case that Antonella Barba should not be the 2007 American Idol winner. No, in our eyes, she shouldn’t even be in the competition any more.

1. Antonella Barba can’t take the heat

Anybody else notice that of all the top 24 contestants, Barba was the most flustered. Her pitch was way off the whole time, she was noticably nervous (nervousness itself isn’t a problem unless it hampers your ability to perform). Then, when she started getting nailed by Simon, she totally choked up and became pathetically defensive.

2. Is Antonella Barba a whore?

Well, maybe that’s a little strong. But take a look. First off, we have pictures of Antonella Barba Topless. That’t not so bad. But then we see pictures surface on the internet of Atonella Barba having naked sex. We had a post here at TV Crunch of one such picture that we were quickly forced to remove. In our opionion, the best collection of shocking nude Antonella Barba pictures, blow job, fountain, wet t-shirt and all can be found here. On top of that, there are numerous pictures around the net of Barba in provocative and seductive poses with other girls, drinking, and partying like she was Miss USA! The point of all this isn’t to be judgemental, but to simply expose the fact that Barba isn’t this innocent Jersey girl that she’s been trying to portray.

3. Antonella Barba can’t perform

She just isn’t that good at singing and performing. She’s rigid and tense. She doesn’t move around the stage well. As the judges pointed out last week, she picked a song that was too big for her voice. But what they failed to point out was that most songs will be too big for her voice.

Considering these 3 points, I fail to see how America can continue to embrace Antonella Barba for much longer. As the truth about her voice, her naked and raunchy adventures, and her generally poor performance under pressure gets exposed, America won’t be able to stand her any longer.

What's Hot At PopCrunch

That was a kickass article. What do I do now?

13 responses so far ↓

Java // Feb 24, 2007 at 7:40 pm

It may be that she truly cannot perform vocally, but she should be judged by her talent (or lack thereof) and NOT by her life mistakes. If America will hypocritically boot her off American Idol because of these pics, we will be a poorer nation because of it. There are all manner of women in the entertainment business making less than desirable life decisions; need we enumerate? I hope that we can always judge them by what they produce talentwise, rather than by their mistakes.
ezine // Feb 26, 2007 at 8:01 am

man, I seriously think this girl is hot but America does not like a college chick that does BJs and poses topless.
Oopsy // Feb 26, 2007 at 11:50 pm

Didn’t Frenchie get kicked off for having topless shots online? I am sure they would rather see Jersey girl with no top, but the rules should be the same for everyone
Jan // Feb 27, 2007 at 12:26 am

I do not see her lasting on American Idol long at all. I was surprised she got to even stay for anther round. This next round I seriously doubt she will make it the third time. She does not have what it takes to succeed. She is a terrible singer. She looked terrified standing up there. What disturbed me the most was seeing her psoe the way she did half nude in front of the war memorial. I am sure I am not the only one who feels that way but that was extremely disrespectful and I can’t tollerate something like that. She is suppose to be a role model for others. That is something she is NOT!!
Jane // Feb 27, 2007 at 6:47 pm

I agree with Oopsy, if Frenchie got kicked off for what she did, and she could actually sing, then this girl should only get the same treatment.
tim // Feb 28, 2007 at 10:21 pm

This girl is very cute, however, a guy like me knows that this is a huge ploy. Go for it girl. I know what you are doing.
skeir // Mar 2, 2007 at 12:01 am

antonella is the worst contestant on AI. she should have been voted off tonight, not Alaina…. the AI voted made a HUGE mistake. no doubt the girl is beautiful, she should enter in Americas Next Top Model…not AI. She’s terrible vocally.
Kelly // Mar 2, 2007 at 7:08 pm

BTW lots of her pics at http://www.barba.in
Antonella // Mar 3, 2007 at 2:55 am

More pic and info at: http://www.schoolmall.ca/antonella+barba.html
stone // Mar 8, 2007 at 8:02 am

Now this chick looks as though she sux a pretty gentle cock. If she would had just slobbed a black mans thunder rod the NCAA wouldn’t be all down her throwt. LOL!!!
ezine // Mar 10, 2007 at 10:02 am

man this girl is HOT. I still love her
Antonella Barba, - Antonella Barba Nude Pictures - American Idol Contestant | Lovely Girls // Apr 7, 2007 at 2:01 pm

[…] The Case Against Antonella Barba | TV CrunchEverybody seems to love Antonella Barba. She�s the darling of America. At the very least, she seems to be the Idol contestant that everyone is talking about … […]
Antonella Barba - Reality TV Magazine: Amanda Coluccio & Antonella Barba, Best … | Lovely Girls // Apr 11, 2007 at 10:57 pm

[…] The Case Against Antonella Barba | TV CrunchEverybody seems to love Antonella Barba. She�s the darling of America. At the very least, she seems to be the Idol contestant that everyone is talking about … […]