Looks like America doesn’t like male strippers — David Hernandez was eliminated on the March 12 American Idol results show.

The March 12 American Idol results show made the first cut of the top 12 finalists. Syesha was the first American Idol contestant named to the bottom three, followed by Kristy Lee Cook and David Hernandez.

Of the bottom three, Syesha was told she was safe and, after 29 million votes, America decided that Kristy Lee Cook was safe and David Hernandez is going home.