This CBS How I Met Your Mother/Frosty the Snowman mashup video is making the rounds today, and while it’s a fairly funny use of Barney’s dialogue, I can’t help but compare it to my favorite, the Scrubs Charlie Brown Christmas.

Take a look at the Scrubs cast doing the Charlie Brown thang, versus the Frosty the Inappopriate Snowman HIMYM video – which is funnier?