Gossip Girl’s Leighton Meester, who plays the bitchy socialite teen Blair Waldorf, was spotted at the New York City Ballet on Tuesday evening, looking gorgeous in a brown gown. She met up with her costar, Nicole Fiscella, who plays Isabel, and she looked equally stunning in her shiny gown.

You could totally believe that it’s the characters themselves at the ballet, considering their high society lifestyles. But then you notice that Leighton is smiling so you know it’s really her and not Blair – Blair never looks that genuinely happy unless she’s busy destroying someone!