Stephen Colbert discusses Conan O’Brien’s ironclad logic that Conan O’Brien made Mike Huckabee… just as Stephen Colbert is about to concede, Jon Stewart drops by to fight the good fight with Colbert, bringing some old timey video (VHS, what?) of when Conan O’Brien was a guest on Jon Stewart’s MTV talk show.

So, who made Huckabee? Check out the video clip above and you’ll see it was actually Jon Stewart who made Huckabee!