David Archuleta sings “(Coming to) America” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said he was in the zone; Paula said this was the perfect song to sing; Simon said that it was a smart song choice, very good.

Brooke White sings “I Am… I Said” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said she did a nice job; Paula said it works, she showed her vulnerability; Simon said this is the Brooke we like and was a million times better than the first song.

David Cook sings “All I Really Need is You” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said he’s a huge David Cook fan, he rocked the house; Paula is proud of him and said she’s already looking at the American Idol; Simon thought it was brilliant.

Jason Castro sings “September Morn” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said it was just okay, not the best; Paula thought it was too safe; Simon thought he struggled through and it was forgettable.

David Archuleta sings “Sweet Caroline” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said it was the bomb; Paula didn’t have time to comment; Simon said it was amateurish.

Syesha Mercado sings “Hello Again” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said her vocals were strong; Paula didn’t have time to comment; Simon thought it was old-fashioned.

Brooke White sings “I’m a Believer” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said she was better than last week; Paula had no time to comment; Simon said it was a nightmare.

David Cook sings “I’m Alive” by Neil Diamond in this April 29 American Idol video clip.

Randy said it was very strong; Paula said he was fantastic; Simon thought he was just above average.