While the former American Idol champ won Entertainer of the Year at the Academy of Country Music Awards, it was Carrie Underwood’s big red dress that practically stole the show at the 2009 ACMs. Check out this picture of Underwood in a huge flowing red dress as she sings “I Told You So” (watch the video of her performance).

Prior to the 2009 ACM performance, Carrie Underwood had teased about wearing a red dress, saying it looked “kind of like water, maybe? Like red water? That sounds scary, doesn’t it? Maybe like lava. It’s like lava. Or icing. Red icing.”