TV Crunch

April 23 American Idol Results Show: Carly Smithson Eliminated

2

April 23rd, 2008 by Wendy

Tagged as: American Idol,Carly Smithson,Fox,Reality TV,Syesha Mercado

Carly Smithson, American Idol
Huh, who would’ve thought that Carly Smithson and Syesha Mercado would be in the bottom two of the April 23 American Idol results show? In the end, Carly Smithson was eliminated.

So, Brooke White and Jason Castro (who I love by the way), were spared the bottom two — what do you think? Huge fan base for these two or votefortheworst at work?

What's Hot at PopCrunch?



2 Comments, add yours

Related Articles:

2 Responses to “April 23 American Idol Results Show: Carly Smithson Eliminated”

  1. On April 23rd 2008, Suzanne wrote:

    I’m SO glad Jason stayed (although I’m sad about Carly who is hugely talented-Brooke should have gone for sure!). I think Jason is really talented and just a slow grower-I think he might give Archuleta a run for his money for the top 2. Particularly if little David doesn’t knock off the ballads.

  2. On April 24th 2008, Braden wrote:

    That’s what I hate about VFTW. I voted for Brooke because I like her, but then I get clumped into their crowd. I guess I’m glad to have their backing tonight, because I am so very very glad to see Carly gone. But that’s just me (and apparently a lot of other people).

What do you think?

comment policy