April 15 American Idol: Carly Smithson Sings “Without You” (Video)
Carly Smithson interviews that American Idol is really boring without Michael Johns! Carly Smithson sings “Without You” by Mariah Carey in this April 15 American Idol video clip.
Randy said he liked that she challenged herself with the song, but thinks she needs to believe in herself, thought it was pretty good; Paula liked how she showed her vocal range; Simon didn’t think she pulled it off and thought it was an okay version.
Related Articles:
- American Idol 7 Finalists: Carly Smithson
- April 23 American Idol Results Show: Carly Smithson Eliminated
- April 8 American Idol: Carly Smithson Sings “The Show Must Go On” (Video)
- April 22 American Idol: Carly Smithson Sings “Jesus Christ Superstar” (Video)
- American Idol Finalist Carly Smithson Says No to Pregnancy Rumors
What's Hot at PopCrunch?
On April 16th 2008, Carol wrote:
I have been watching and listening to Carly every week, and now I can figure out why she didn’t sell any records when she was signed to a label. She does have a good voice, but in my opinion, she can only carry one tune and that’s not good enough to be an American Idol. Unfortunately, the one I thought that had the real shot next to David Cook was dismissed last week. But never fear, MJ will be as Clay and Daughtry, and I will buy his music like I did their’s.