Carly Smithson, 23, of San Diego, California has a sad “American Idol” story – the Irish singer made it through to Hollywood in the show’s fifth season, but her Visa paperwork didn’t come through in time and she was disqualified.

In this “American Idol 7” San Diego audition video clip, Carly Smithson sings “I’m Every Woman” and of course, makes it through to Hollywood. Nothing is stopping the tatoo shop owner this time and Carly Smithson is so unique that she will likely stay in the competition because she’s not forgettable like some of the other women.